Documented case · 2023
Azadzadeh, Iranian developer
2023
Verified primary source
The account holder's own post, discussion or thread was opened and read in full for this entry.
A new account, used for censorship-circumvention repos and a Persian Hugo static site built through Actions and Pages, suspended without a single warning, with only a generic Terms violation given. Three reinstatement requests in two weeks went unanswered. The harm he itemises is the erasure pattern in miniature: a gist holding his English translation of a Chinese circumvention blog was lost; the site's GitHub Pages address, which had circulated on social media and Telegram, went 404 and its readers never returned; and all of his comments, issues, and commit information were, in his word, shadowed.
GitHub, in its own words
"After further investigation of this particular account, we've determined that the account will need to remain flagged."
The record
- Suspended or flagged
- 2023; the account was about a month old
- Posted
- Hacker News, 2023
- Ticket / discussion
- Three reinstatement requests in two weeks, unanswered
- Suspected trigger
- Disputed. After about a month he reached GitHub through Twitter and was told the next day that Actions had been used "to interact with 3rd party websites, to engage in incentivized activities." He says that is false: the only Actions use was building a Hugo static site. His own inferences: a donation address in his profile, or starring and forking a circumvention-tool repo
- Human reply from GitHub
- Yes, once, via Twitter after a month: the answer was the refusal quoted below
- How it ended
- Never restored at posting. He moved to Codeberg and then Netlify
- Duration
- 1 to 3 months
Suspected triggers are the account holder’s inference, never GitHub-confirmed, unless the record above says GitHub stated or confirmed it. A suspension does not by itself prove GitHub made a mistake.
Sources
First-hand post by Azadzadeh, Hacker News item 34817163; read via search text on November 17, 2026.
This entry is one of 66 in What Kind of Life Does a Flag Preserve?, a documented account of GitHub suspending a fourteen-year-old developer account and the same pattern repeating across the industry. If the same thing has happened to you, the article’s eight-step playbook is built from what actually moved these cases.